Spruce Aphid

2 – Trees/Forests At Risk

Hosts

In Alaska, spruce aphid infests spruce species, especially Sitka spruce. Neither tree size nor age influences whether a tree will be infested with spruce aphids; however, tree location is important. In Alaska, spruce in coastal areas and trees stressed by urban and landscape situations are particularly susceptible to damage caused by spruce aphid. Spruce aphids can be found at higher elevations in Alaska if other environmental factors are favorable.

Known distribution

Spruce aphids have been present in Southeast Alaska for decades. A few notable populations have also been detected throughout the years along Prince William Sound, the south side of the Kenai Peninsula, and the Kodiak Archipelago. In 2015, spruce aphids and spruce aphid damage were detected on the south side of Kachemak Bay and in Homer, representing the first record of these aphids on the western side of the Kenai Peninsula. In 2016, damage continued in these areas and was also noted on several islands of the Kodiak Archipelago.

Kenai Peninsula Spruce Aphid Surveys: March, May, June October.
During surveys conducted between spring and fall of 2016, sites with spruce-aphid infested trees were mapped. Not all locations were surveyed during each trip. (Dubois, G. and S. Swenson. 2016. Homer Spruce Aphid Monitoring and Expantion. Trip Report filed October 17, 2016. R10-S&PF-FHP-2016.)
Aphid damage mapped over time
This map shows areas of spruce aphid damage statewide that were mapped between 1981 and 2015. Recent activity is designated by year. Southeast Alaska has seen several spruce aphid outbreaks at various locations in the decades since the pest was first established there.

Weather factors affecting populations

Spruce aphids are a climate-limited pest. As shown above, spruce aphid distribution in Alaska has previously been limited to milder areas of the state. Colder temperatures can play a couple of roles in limiting aphid populations. Aphids become inactive at or below approximately 42 °F (Powell and Parry 1976); prolonged periods of cold can kill aphids outright or result in starvation. Many aphids die at temperatures at or below approximately 19 °F. If aphids are actively feeding on needles, most aphids will die at temperatures at or below 14 °F because of the formation of ice crystals in the tree sap that is transferred to the aphid during feeding. If aphids are not actively feeding and are detached from the needles they may survive to lower temperatures. When temperatures remain relatively low for prolonged periods of time but above the lethal temperatures, spruce aphid mortality may still occur and can negatively impact aphid population levels.

Spruce aphid outbreaks tend to follow mild winters where temperatures remain above freezing. Field observations suggest that two or more successive warmer winters may be needed for populations to outbreak. Other factors also contribute to spruce aphid population changes such as density of aphids on the host plant and the presence of natural enemies.

How to ID an infestation

What to look for – Needle discoloration   

Spruce tree with needle discoloration due to heavy spruce aphid feeding
Damage to Sitka spruce resulting from spruce aphid feeding.( Region 10, US Forest Service, www.fs.usda.gov)

Often the symptoms of a spruce aphid infestation are noticed before the insects themselves are observed. Unfortunately, the symptoms can sometime occur well after the damage has been done. Yellowing and browning of older needles followed by premature needle drop are the two main symptoms of spruce aphid infestation. Needle yellowing may appear on all or parts of individual needles, depending on the extent of the infestation. Individual needles may appear yellow or brown at different rates than surrounding needles. This discoloration is often observed in the summer after the majority of aphid feeding has ceased from the spring.

What to look for – Presence of aphids 

Aphids on spruce needles and individual needles with aphid feeding damage. (Region 10, US Forest Service, www.fs.usda.gov)
Aphids on spruce needles and individual needles with aphid feeding damage. (Region 10, US Forest Service, www.fs.usda.gov)

Confirming that spruce aphid is the cause of your tree health issues can be difficult based on symptoms alone. Finding actual aphids is important in determining proper control measures for the pest.

Single aphid on a spruce needle. Note the yellow and orange discoloration due to feeding damage. (Region 10, US Forest Service, www.fs.usda.gov)
Single aphid on a spruce needle. Note the yellow and orange discoloration due to feeding damage. (Region 10, US Forest Service, www.fs.usda.gov)

Visually inspect trees for the presence of aphids. Check previously infested trees and nearby trees starting in mid to late winter when temperatures are mild. Check the undersides of needles and older needles for the presence of adult and immature aphids. Monitor weekly through spring to note any increases in numbers of aphids on the tree. This method is good for small to medium sized trees where many branches are within reach or at eye-level.

Another method for monitoring for spruce aphid is referred to as the “beat sheet” method. Traditionally, this method uses a large piece of fabric stretched over a sturdy frame which is held beneath vegetation. A pole or stick is used to tap on the branches to dislodge insects which fall onto the fabric and can then be collected, counted, observed, etc. This method may be easier on larger trees with higher branches. If the goal is simply to determine if the pest is present, a simple set up using a clipboard or other sturdy surface with a piece of plain copy paper can substitute for the traditional gear. Simply hold the paper beneath the branches and tap them with a pole or stick to dislodge anything onto the paper where it can be further examined.

This short video shows how to use a beat sheet. While it is geared toward trees in orchard production, the principles of use and equipment are the same.

Whether visually inspecting individual branches or trying the beat sheet method, monitor trees weekly through the spring. Check trees again in the fall for autumn populations.

What’s NOT spruce aphid

Needlecast diseases

There are several diseases that can cause needles to change color and drop from trees. Needlecast may be caused by one of a handful of fungi that infect needles or twigs. Once the infection occurs it can take a year or so before the symptoms are noticeable. Needlecast damage is very similar to spruce aphid damage in that the older needles are affected while the current year’s growth remains green. It can be difficult to distinguish needlecast from spruce aphid damage. The presence of aphids can help differentiate the damage as well as the presence of needlecast fruiting bodies on the needles.

Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce.
Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce. ( USDA Forest Service-North Central Research Station, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org)

Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce.
Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce. (USDA Forest Service, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org)

Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce.
Symptoms of needle cast disease in spruce. (Paul E. Hennon, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org)

Giant conifer aphids

Many aphids may be observed on spruce trees; however, not all aphids will cause the same damage as spruce aphid. As their name implies, giant conifer aphids are much larger than spruce aphids and can be 2-5 mm long. Giant conifer aphids are also brown in color versus the bright green of spruce aphids. Additionally giant conifer aphids are rarely found on needles as they feed on branches and stems.

Giant Conifer Aphids
Giant conifer aphids on spruce twig. Giant conifer aphids are larger than spruce aphids and dark gray to black in color.(Edward H. Holsten, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org)

Woolly adelgids

Woolly adelgids are small insects that are very closely related to aphids. They have similar feeding styles and can cause similar damage to needles when populations are high. Woolly adelgids can be distinguished from spruce aphids because the insects produce a waxy substance to cover their bodies and protect them while they are feeding. The waxy secretions look like woolly tufts along the needles of the trees. Spruce aphids do not produce the woolly tufts.

: Woolly adelgids on spruce needles
Woolly adelgids on spruce needles. Each white fluffy tuft is an individual, some will also have clusters of eggs. (Whitney Cranshaw, Colorado State University, Bugwood.org)

Other conditions

Other conditions can result in needle discoloration and early needle drop. Drought, root damage, and chemical damage can all lead to discoloration and drop in spruce trees. There can also be some bit of natural needle drop within spruce trees. Over time, a tree may not need all of the needles it has ever produced in its life and will shed those that are not as efficient or productive. The presence of aphids and the history of the tree are the best ways to distinguish between these conditions and spruce aphid damage.

: Spruce needle discoloration due to drought conditions.
Spruce needle discoloration due to drought conditions.(Petr Kapitola, Central Institute for Supervising and Testing in Agruculture, Bugwood.org)

Spruce needle discoloration due to herbicide (atrazine).
Spruce needle discoloration due to herbicide (atrazine). (USDA Forest Service-Ogden, USDA Forest Service, Bugwood.org)

It is also important to note that there is always the possibility for more than one of these pests or conditions to be occurring simultaneously. Take the time to check the trees and note observations of health before determining cause.

Continue to Module 3